Reviewer consensus

Apple AirPods Max vs Sony WH-1000XM5

The Sony WH-1000XM5 leads on battery life and price.

Noise cancelling and sound are level. The AirPods Max still holds the better transparency mode and build quality. On 4 of the 10 topics the two are too close to call.

Counted from 75 reviewers who bought and tested both. We have not tested these headphones ourselves — every number below is a count of independent people, and links to the second they said it. Half of them covered the two within the same month of each other, and 63 of 73 within a year.

Apple AirPods Max review by UrAvgConsumer
Apple AirPods Max review by SoundGuysApple AirPods Max review by Karenna BoychukApple AirPods Max review by Andrew Ethan ZengApple AirPods Max review by Brian Tong

From 91 videos by the 75 reviewers who covered both

Apple AirPods Max

Reviewers preferred it on

2 of 10 topics

Best on transparency mode — 18 of 19 reviewers liked it

Sony WH-1000XM5 review by Marques Brownlee
Sony WH-1000XM5 review by This is Tech TodaySony WH-1000XM5 review by Mark Ellis ReviewsSony WH-1000XM5 review by Darko AudioSony WH-1000XM5 review by 6 Months Later

From 116 videos by the 75 reviewers who covered both

Sony WH-1000XM5

Reviewers preferred it on

4 of 10 topics

Best on noise cancellation — 30 of 30 reviewers liked it

All 10 topics at a glance

Every topic at least 8 of the 75 reviewers discussed on both models. Percentages are the share who rated it positively. Pick one to jump to the evidence.

Topic AirPods Max Sony WH-1000XM5 Verdict
Battery life0% 0 of 1282% 9 of 11Sony WH-1000XM5 ahead
Price and value18% 2 of 1175% 15 of 20Sony WH-1000XM5 ahead
Transparency mode95% 18 of 1946% 6 of 13AirPods Max ahead
Comfort and fit19% 5 of 2664% 23 of 36Sony WH-1000XM5 ahead
Microphone quality on calls62% 5 of 8100% 13 of 13Sony WH-1000XM5 ahead
Design and build quality65% 17 of 2644% 18 of 41AirPods Max ahead
Noise cancellation88% 23 of 26100% 30 of 30too close to call
Bluetooth and connectivity64% 9 of 1475% 12 of 16too close to call
Sound quality75% 21 of 2869% 29 of 42too close to call
The carrying case20% 3 of 1517% 4 of 23too close to call

Where they differ

Each square is one reviewer; filled squares rated that topic positively. One reviewer counts once per topic, so these measure how many people agreed — not how loudly. A topic appears only where at least 8 reviewers covered it on both models.

Sony WH-1000XM5 is better at

Battery life

Most reviewers liked the Sony WH-1000XM5’s battery life. Most of the ones who discussed the AirPods Max’s did not.

Sony WH-1000XM59 of 11 reviewers liked it

Apple AirPods Max0 of 12 reviewers liked it

GYMCADDY’s review, at 3:54
“both of Sony's headphones, they have an advertised battery life of 30 hours with the active noise cancellation turned on and they can also go for 40 hours with their active noise cancellation turned off.”
GYMCADDY · 176k subscribers · Aug 2023
Beats Studio Pro vs Sony 1000XM5 & Sony 1000XM4
Watch this moment at 3:54 →
What reviewers said about Battery life (12 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“These have great battery life at 30 hours. Now that's comparable to most of the headphones that these compete with and they beat out the AirPods Max by a full 10 hours.”

6 Months Later · 2:14 · Nov 2025 →

“The Sony XM5s are advertised to have a 30 hour battery life compared to Apple's 20 hour battery life is something to keep in mind before purchasing these.”

Erick · 2:40 · Jan 2024 →

“Sony actually smokes Apple. You're getting up to 30 hours on the XM6 opposed to 20 hours on the AirPods Max.”

SimplyPops · 6:15 · May 2025 →

“30 hours of battery life which is really good for headphones and is 10 hours longer than the AirPods Max”

AGU Tech · 0:31 · Jan 2024 →
What they criticised

“Sony, this charging cable is too short. This is not useful in 90% of use cases”

Digital Trends · 3:05 · May 2022 →

“The XM-5 sounded fine, but needed a charger way too often.”

Verified Reviews · 1:14 · Jan 2026 →

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“I think the battery life is more than adequate”

Colt Capperrune 2.0 · 4:36 · Nov 2022 →
What they criticised

“the lack of the on-off button is one of the biggest gripes that I have with these headphones to this day. And since left in the case day-to-day to use, they're usually dead unless I'm charging them every second day.”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 2:34 · Apr 2023 →

“they'll detect some kind of motion and then I'll see it pop up on my phone as it just connected... sometimes I'll come back to the headphone and notice that a huge chunk of the battery life has gone down a bit”

UrAvgConsumer · 8:12 · Dec 2020 →

“the AirPods Max due to not having a true off mode basically when you're not wearing them and they're inactive for some time or you put them into the smart case that they're supposed to go into this low power state so they're technically…”

RecordingNOW · 3:51 · May 2025 →

“the AirPods Max 2 is the most expensive, the heaviest, has the shortest battery, and lacks wireless high-res audio.”

Headphones Pro Review · 8:35 · Apr 2026 →

and 1 more with something to say here

Price and value

Most reviewers liked the Sony WH-1000XM5’s price. Most of the ones who discussed the AirPods Max’s did not.

Sony WH-1000XM515 of 20 reviewers liked it

Apple AirPods Max2 of 11 reviewers liked it

Skeeb23’s review, at 22:42
“the WXM5 still can make a strong case for anybody in 2025 because first of all this headphone can be found used as I said for around the $200 range... or you should be able to find it new even probably on sale…”
Skeeb23 · 6k subscribers · Jul 2025
Sony WH-1000XM6 vs WH-1000XM5: Which Headphones Actually Win?
Watch this moment at 22:42 →
What reviewers said about Price and value (28 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“the WXM5 still can make a strong case for anybody in 2025 because first of all this headphone can be found used as I said for around the $200 range... or you should be able to find it new even probably on sale in that $300 range”

Skeeb23 · 22:42 · Jul 2025 →

“I would say these are the best active noise cancelling headphones that you can get for the money. That $50 price bump I'm not the happiest about... $50 extra bucks I would have loved to see the case just be a bit more robust”

Karl Conrad · 8:45 · May 2022 →

“I've been using these headphones for about three years now. And they're not perfect. But with the price dropping nearly 50% since launch, this might be the only time they're actually worth it”

Mr K · 0:02 →

“This is why I think the M5 is going to be one of the best headphones I've ever used even though I haven't fully used it yet.”

Andy Tran · 5:17 →

and 10 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“while you're probably not going to like their higher $400 price tag”

CNET · 0:11 · May 2022 →

“The one potential sticky point was that launch price of £380 pounds”

Smart Home Sounds · 1:43 · Feb 2024 →

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“The AirPods Max still have features that make sense for the amount of money you're paying... like they're much smarter than these beats headphones... I think that they sound better and they have an insanely good build quality...”

GregsGadgets · 10:30 · Jul 2023 →

“if you have the budget for it they're still a great buy especially considering we do not yet know when the AirPods Max 2 are scheduled to be dropped.”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 8:09 · Apr 2023 →

“the AirPods Max 2 are a solid buy”

SoundGuys · 13:57 · Apr 2026 →
What they criticised

“at $549, these are a very premium product and in fact it's still one of the most expensive headphones on the market and I can understand why it's a big turn off for some people. Although I think the price tag is justified to an extent and…”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 1:14 · Apr 2023 →

“$550. These are not a good value. It doesn't matter how you spin it, these are expensive. Now, they're not meant to be a good value. They're meant to be a premium luxury product from Apple...”

Dave2D · 9:29 · Dec 2020 →

“you need to spend an additional $35 for a Lightning to 3.5mm cable which may be the worst flimsiest audio cable of all time at an embarrassingly short range.”

GregsGadgets · 2:32 · Jul 2023 →

“most people expect expensive headphones that consumers would buy to be around the $300 price point”

UrAvgConsumer · 0:51 · Dec 2020 →

and 5 more with something to say here

Comfort and fit

Reviewers preferred the Sony WH-1000XM5’s comfort.

Sony WH-1000XM523 of 36 reviewers liked it

Apple AirPods Max5 of 26 reviewers liked it

Nikias Molina’s review, at 1:31
“And when I say light, they are very light. With the AirPods Max, it's got such a big headphone band that it's really uncomfortable when traveling, plus the AirPods Max are very, very heavy, so for traveling…”
Nikias Molina · 420k subscribers · Jun 2022
Sony WH-1000XM5 - how they (actually) are.
Watch this moment at 1:31 →
What reviewers said about Comfort and fit (82 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“the head clamp force on the Sony, I think it's just perfect especially for long usage or you know for people that are just using it at a desk or while travelling, commuting, just regular everyday usage, the amount of clamp force on this is…”

Tausif Hussain · 4:14 · Dec 2023 →

“And when I say light, they are very light. With the AirPods Max, it's got such a big headphone band that it's really uncomfortable when traveling, plus the AirPods Max are very, very heavy, so for traveling, it just did not convince me.”

Nikias Molina · 1:31 · Jun 2022 →

“The headband also feels more comfortable against my head, but it's not because there's more cushioning... but it's because the new headband flexes in a wider arc so more cushion is making contact against your head”

Aaron X Loud and Wireless · 3:20 · May 2022 →

“so these are good for active people that's what I'm just this is what I'm trying to get at being active and you want some headphones you can wear through the day not have to worry about them doing the most”

RJ Uploads · 2:49 · Jul 2025 →

and 28 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“Add some Sony headphones back in the day that I didn't realize for a long time why I didn't use them that often... my head one is getting super hot because of these just clamp down so hard and then second thing they clamp down super hard…”

RDGMT · 2:38 · Jun 2026 →

“I find that it isn't quite as comfortable as larger headbands maybe that's just because the pressure is more localized and in one spot and that's one of the main reasons why Apple designed their AirPods Max is with this large mesh area it…”

Karl Conrad · 3:38 · May 2022 →

“The earpads on the XM5s have a very wide diameter to them, however, they are very shallow. So I found that even if you have average size ears, these shallow earpads can press down on your cartilage, which does get uncomfortable after a…”

GYMCADDY · 5:30 · Jun 2024 →

“the Sonys, you know, even when I tighten it down, it kind of feels like it's going to fall off. I have to always tilt it so that if I'm lying down on a bench, I'm kind of wearing my headphones like this...”

Tausif Hussain · 4:51 · Dec 2023 →

and 14 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“Even though they're heavier than the XM5s, I actually find the AirPods Max to be a more comfortable set of headphones for a few reasons. First one is the mesh material used here on the mesh canopy. It allows the heat generated from your…”

6 Months Later · 3:46 · Nov 2022 →

“Although very heavy, some 150 grams on top of other brands, the weight is very interestingly distributed and the usual tension is not clamping my ears, but rather the tops of my head, resulting in a somewhat evenly distributed experience.”

ThisIsE · 2:11 · Jan 2021 →

“these have a pretty decent clamping force and what I mean by that is that these will you know sit snugly on your ears but thankfully they're over-ear headphones so they're not going to put any pressure on the ears themselves”

UrAvgConsumer · 1:36 · Dec 2020 →

“These are also comfortable too as well... breathable material... the headband, one of the best in class, this canopy design is just one of a kind”

SimplyPops · 5:30 · Jul 2023 →

and 9 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“they're not a super strong clamping force headphone, so you can't just kind of like rely on them to hold themselves up or rather you might be able to, except that they're so bloody heavy that over time they tend to make their way down and…”

ShortCircuit · 3:08 · Apr 2026 →

“I can feel that these are heavier than all of my headphones that I've owned before... I did go for a run with them... and there's just so much mass to these that every step you take... the momentum of them going up and down, it's not a…”

Dave2D · 3:26 · Dec 2020 →

“Because of that material choice, the AirPods Max are just not comfortable and you cannot listen to them for long extended periods of time without your head starting to hurt.”

Marc Taraz Steiner · 1:15 · Jun 2025 →

“I've seen a lot of people complain about the weight of these saying that they're pretty heavy. This is substantially heavier than a lot of headphones out there right now”

UrAvgConsumer · 3:06 · Dec 2020 →

and 15 more with something to say here

Microphone quality on calls

Reviewers liked both, but were clearly happier with the Sony WH-1000XM5’s microphone.

Sony WH-1000XM513 of 13 reviewers liked it

Apple AirPods Max5 of 8 reviewers liked it

Digital Trends’s review, at 6:21
“No question the XM5 are better. If you spend a lot of time on the phone... the XM5 will basically erase any background noise going on. Barking dogs, jackhammer... the XM5 will make you sound like you're all…”
Digital Trends · May 2022
Sony WH-1000XM5 vs. WH-1000XM4 | Time to upgrade?
Watch this moment at 6:21 →
What reviewers said about Microphone quality on calls (10 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“No question the XM5 are better. If you spend a lot of time on the phone... the XM5 will basically erase any background noise going on. Barking dogs, jackhammer... the XM5 will make you sound like you're all alone”

Digital Trends · 6:21 · May 2022 →

“they'll still improve like like in every condition noisy conditions windy conditions, they dealt with any kind of things you threw at them”

DHRME · 2:08 · May 2026 →

“So after using both long-term the XM5s are clearly better for calls reliability and battery life”

Mr K · 3:56 →

“I dare say that the XM5s may be right now the best in terms of microphone pickup.”

Aaron X Loud and Wireless · 8:05 · May 2022 →

and 4 more with something to say here

What they criticised

No reviewer said this in words we could verify.

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“I think only the AirPods Max really have better voice quality.”

Digital Trends · 6:56 · May 2022 →
What they criticised

“The AirPods Max on the other hand, they use three mics in total out of the eight built-in ones to pick up your voice and I don't like it either.”

LeechTM · 8:52 · Jun 2024 →
AirPods Max is better at

Transparency mode

Most reviewers liked the AirPods Max’s transparency mode. Most of the ones who discussed the Sony WH-1000XM5’s did not.

Apple AirPods Max18 of 19 reviewers liked it

Sony WH-1000XM56 of 13 reviewers liked it

“the transparency mode on the AirPods Max it basically sounds like not wearing headphones at all. It is still the best transparency mode I have ever experienced on a pair of noise canceling headphones or…”
6 Months Later · 299k subscribers · Nov 2022
AirPods Max vs. Sony WH-1000XM5
Watch this moment at 7:00 →
What reviewers said about Transparency mode (24 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“The XM5's transparency is still the one to beat and frankly it's awesome even compared to headphones from other brands. It could even rival the AirPods Max.”

Aaron X Loud and Wireless · 5:03 · Apr 2024 →

“The transparency mode is also quite good on these and sounds I'd say just it's a step below the AirPods Max which still have the best transparency mode”

6 Months Later · 3:12 · Nov 2025 →

“yes my over the-top Sony's which have some probably the best uh transparency mode on any pair of headphones I've used so far”

RJ Uploads · 12:26 · Jul 2025 →

“put your hand over and this will switch quite quickly to the ambient mode.”

How To · 3:32 · Dec 2024 →

and 3 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“when you're listening to transparency mode on the XM5s, it still kind of sounds like you're underwater a bit”

6 Months Later · 5:35 · Nov 2022 →

“Oh, that is not a very good ambient mode.”

ShortCircuit · 8:00 · May 2022 →

“There is also an adaptive sound control feature that can be turned on allowing the headphones and the app to detect your actions and automatically switch how ambient sound is filtered. Theoretically this could be good when traveling by bus…”

The Source Audio Video Design Group · 3:07 · Dec 2023 →

“Sony's ambient mode is good, but it still has that slight digital hiss and robotic tint to voices that reminds you you're listening through microphones.”

Everything Under Control · 4:46 · Dec 2025 →

and 2 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“the transparency mode on the AirPods Max it basically sounds like not wearing headphones at all. It is still the best transparency mode I have ever experienced on a pair of noise canceling headphones or earbuds. And compared to the XM5s…”

6 Months Later · 7:00 · Nov 2022 →

“Apple has one of the best transparency mode what I think when I have compare them to the the Sony XM5s and other brands, so I think that Apple is on top when it comes to the transparency mode”

ThisisHazno · 4:36 · Sep 2024 →

“Those are the best I've ever heard in any headphones. It sounds like you're not wearing headphones, you just hear everyone's voices and everything perfectly clearly”

Marques Brownlee · 4:47 · May 2022 →

“Transparency it sounds like I don't even have the headphones on... it just it feels one-to-one.”

SimplyPops · 7:54 · Jul 2023 →

and 6 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“they do tend to exaggerate the upper mid and high frequencies a bit more to give that sense of crispness, which inadvertently ends up sounding less natural”

Aaron X Loud and Wireless · 5:45 · Jun 2024 →

Design and build quality

Reviewers preferred the AirPods Max’s build quality.

Apple AirPods Max17 of 26 reviewers liked it

Sony WH-1000XM518 of 41 reviewers liked it

GregsGadgets’s review, at 3:52
“These are solid. Like hands down the best build quality that I have ever seen in a pair of headphones. Then yeah, they're made from actual aluminum and you know they got a nice mesh fabric cup. They have…”
GregsGadgets · Jul 2023
Beats Studio Pro VS AirPods Max - DON'T BE FOOLED!
Watch this moment at 3:52 →
What reviewers said about Design and build quality (72 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“I think durability deserves a special mention with the XM5s and they are a bit of a winner in that area, which is a surprise because when you first get these and first get them out the box, they are unnervingly light.”

Mark Ellis Reviews · 4:09 · Aug 2022 →

“Now the 1000XM5 from Sony on the other hand makes a solid first impression with a fresh and clean design, clear sound, and an even better ANC.”

Audio Zone · 1:52 · Jul 2023 →

“The next thing I'd like about the XM5s are their lighter weight, weighing only 249 grams, compared to the AirPods Max, which weigh 384 grams.”

6 Months Later · 2:00 · Nov 2022 →

“day to day the XM5s definitely feel like newer headphones the materials are durable and comfort wise you can tell Sony's refined the design”

Mr K · 2:28 →

and 15 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“If you look at the hinge design here, this has been a notorious issue online and I have seen examples of this hinge breaking. To get down to this lightweight, Sony did use quite a lot of plastic, but the hinge here is really the weak point.”

RecordingNOW · 3:51 · Mar 2025 →

“These feel really plasticky and really cheap and the design of it is absolutely beautiful. But once you actually hold them in your hands, they feel extremely cheap, they're extremely flexible.”

Nikias Molina · 1:10 · Jun 2022 →

“when you wear these headphones, they just stick out of your head a bit more than some other pairs of headphones out on the market and to me they just kind of look ugly.”

6 Months Later · 6:06 · Nov 2022 →

“Sony's headphones have this reputation of usually breaking at the hinges 'cause they're mostly plastic. And this was definitely a big issue with the XM5s.”

GYMCADDY · 5:29 · Jun 2025 →

and 24 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“These are solid. Like hands down the best build quality that I have ever seen in a pair of headphones. Then yeah, they're made from actual aluminum and you know they got a nice mesh fabric cup. They have precise telescoping arms so they…”

GregsGadgets · 3:52 · Jul 2023 →

“if you're fully immersed in the Apple ecosystem and don't really care that these weigh a little bit more due to the premium materials that you'll find on these, as well as really care about that sound bleeding issue that you'll find on the…”

Erick · 3:58 · Jan 2024 →

“Apple's design with soft mesh, the heavier metals and in terms of like premium looking finish you can see where it actually lands here as you compare both of them.”

Booredatwork.com · 5:30 · May 2026 →

“That means you still get that premium metal build, breathable mesh headband, and large cushioned earcups that helped define the first model's identity.”

OASTHAR · 1:27 · Mar 2026 →

and 12 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“As a start, although the imprinted left and right symbols into the ear cups are fantastically made and a minimal choice for many people, in certain situations, when working in darker environments, for example, it is difficult to figure out…”

ThisIsE · 7:16 · Jan 2021 →

“Now, metal earcups give the AirPods Max a very distinct look, but it introduces a couple issues. Number one, weight: these are definitely heavier... Secondly, durability... the aluminum... can be scratched...”

Dave2D · 2:05 · Dec 2020 →

“there's no protection here against condensation build up. That's an issue that's plagued many AirPods Max customers that have been left with dead devices after a few short months.”

iFixit · 5:31 · Apr 2026 →

“anyone hoping for a slimmer profile or a dramatic redesign, may feel slightly underwhelmed because visually, the two headphones look almost identical at first glance.”

OASTHAR · 1:47 · Mar 2026 →

and 5 more with something to say here

All 10 topics at a glance

Where they are the same

On these 4 topics the two are within 15 points of each other. Percentages are the share of reviewers who came down positively on balance, so “both rated well” means both are good — not that neither stood out. A reviewer who praised a topic and also raised a caveat counts as positive here, and the caveat still appears under “what they criticised”, which is why a topic can read 100% and still have criticism attached to it.

Too close to call
Noise cancellationAlmost everyone liked both — 88% and 100% of reviewers liked them
What reviewers said about Noise cancellation (52 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“the XM5s already feel like a substantial upgrade. Its ANC, its transparency, and its microphone pickup is a full generation ahead of the XM4s... it's looking to me like these have right now the best noise cancelling performance in the…”

Aaron X Loud and Wireless · 13:46 · May 2022 →

“The Sony XM5s do have one saving grace. If you're after a pair of headphones that have the absolute best noise cancelling on the market and you're willing to make some compromises or accept some compromises for that, they cannot be beaten.”

Mark Ellis Reviews · 4:42 · Aug 2023 →

“This was the best active noise cancelling experience I've had with a pair of headphones. It was noticeably better and more quieter on the Mark 5s compared to the AirPods Pros or even the Mark 3s”

Karl Conrad · 5:36 · May 2022 →

“In summary, the Sony WH-1000XM5SA combines industry-leading noise cancellation, high-resolution sound, long battery life, and superior comfort into a sleek and stylish over-ear design.”

finderBinder · 4:08 →

and 31 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“Well one review did mention it wasn't perfect during a plane taking off unless they manually tweaked something”

Tech Talk Central · 3:27 →

“The one caveat with the noise canceling, similar to the B&W PX7 S2e headphones, is that the base quantity is increased when the noise cancellation is active”

The Source Audio Video Design Group · 2:33 · Dec 2023 →

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“It's very comfortable in a way that is hard to fully describe other than that they just don't really apply that same that ANC pressure that you get with some other solutions while also covering an extremely broad band of audio frequencies…”

ShortCircuit · 3:39 · Apr 2026 →

“For the active noise cancellation and transparency mode that you'll find on both of these headphones, I think the AirPods Max takes it, especially in the transparency mode. I just think the microphones that are in the AirPods Max make…”

Erick · 3:00 · Jan 2024 →

“the active noise cancellation is also beyond top notch. It does the best job in blocking out external noise to the point where I almost forgot the hum of the plane on flights until I stopped using them.”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 5:22 · Apr 2023 →

“These do a really good job of blocking out consistent noise like fans, or planes, or street noise, but what really impressed me is how well they handle voices and more irregular sounds, like dog barks.”

Tech Fowler · 4:13 · Apr 2026 →

and 8 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“I actually didn't find the AirPods Max noise canceling to be as good as some people online say I think it's because of the physical seal is not as good due to having this rectangular earcup shape and also not having these really…”

RecordingNOW · 5:07 · May 2025 →

“while at cruising altitude, both the XM5s and XM4s were able to block out way more noise than let's say the Bose QC Ultra, Bose QC headphones, AirPods Max, or Sennheiser Momentum 4s.”

GYMCADDY · 20:39 · Jun 2025 →

“I find the ANC on the AirPods Max very aggressive.”

KwasiTechSpace · 2:00 · Jun 2024 →
Sound qualityAlmost everyone liked both — 75% and 69% of reviewers liked them
What reviewers said about Sound quality (64 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“The Beats Studio Pro have somehow mastered the art of the daily driver headphones. The case, the fit, the comfort, the battery life, the looks which aren't too garish, the sound which isn't completely class-leading, but does a fantastic…”

Mark Ellis Reviews · 4:17 · Aug 2023 →

“they've got great battery life, are lightweight, have a full protective case for travelling, multipoint connectivity, and good sound quality. But because of their fit, they're typically not the headphones I'm picking up to listen to things…”

6 Months Later · 6:23 · Nov 2022 →

“Overall though, the Sony XM5s have been my go to I think just with that combination of sound canceling that doesn't annoy me, a sound profile that to me at least sounds good and I enjoy both for voice and also for music.”

Steven Foster · 5:44 · Dec 2023 →

“These over-ear headphones are designed for music lovers, travelers, and professionals alike, offering an immersive listening experience whether you're on a plane, working in a busy office, or just relaxing at home.”

finderBinder · 0:28 →

and 31 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“One very important thing I would like to point out though about the Sony XM5s is that they have a very bad sound bleeding issue. And what that basically means is that if I have these headphones playing at full volume, the person sitting…”

Erick · 3:14 · Jan 2024 →

“the XM5s, the XM4s as well as the XM3s are always some of the worst sounding ANC headphones that I have ever used. This is some generational genetic trash.”

crinacle · 3:09 · Jun 2025 →

“the mark 5s started to feel a little spiky in the midrange where the vocals are and were a little bit weaker in the low end”

Marques Brownlee · 4:39 · May 2025 →

“By default, I think the XM5s are a little heavy in the mids and definitely a bit heavy with the bass.”

6 Months Later · 2:08 · Nov 2022 →

and 6 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“Well, if you're an Apple user, you've got an iPhone and a bunch of other Apple products like a Mac, iPad, Apple TV, especially you should go with the AirPods Max. It is not even close. They're pretty much better than the XM5s in every…”

6 Months Later · 9:04 · Nov 2022 →

“plugging these headphones in via the 3.5mm adapter made the experience even richer and it's truly as good as it gets. Honestly it sounds as close to true lossless audio as possible to the point where I really highly doubt you'd be able to…”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 5:00 · Apr 2023 →

“They sound better, the noise cancelling is better, the features are finally up to date, but at the same time, they feel almost exactly the same as the originals from 2020.”

Tech Fowler · 0:05 · Apr 2026 →

“I'm still going to give the edge to the AirPods Max... computational audio, adaptive EQs... it sounds a little bit more richer on the AirPods Max”

SimplyPops · 10:16 · Jul 2023 →

and 11 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“actually the sound quality from these I feel that these should be about the same price as these because they kind of sound the same.”

Redskull · 13:40 · Jun 2024 →

“If you're into bass heavy club style music, you might feel a bit underwhelming. There's definitely a warmth to the vocals.”

Kevin The Tech Ninja · 8:29 · May 2025 →

“The note definition in the sub-bass, so we're talking 100 Hz and below, it definitely leaves something to be desired.”

Colt Capperrune 2.0 · 7:30 · Nov 2022 →

“So on the AirPods Maxes I do feel like yes, it also sounds a bit muffled and not quite as clear as I like it to be”

crinacle · 9:50 · Jun 2025 →
Bluetooth and connectivityOpinions were split on both — 64% and 75% of reviewers liked them
What reviewers said about Bluetooth and connectivity (22 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“whereas the Sony's on the other hand, you can plug these in just with a 3.5 millimeter headphone jack and you can still use them as regular old headphones. You don't have to turn it on.”

Tausif Hussain · 9:08 · Dec 2023 →

“If you don't have any Apple devices in your life to be able to set up and maintain the firmware on the AirPods Max then yeah, the XM5s are really your only choice.”

6 Months Later · 10:18 · Nov 2022 →

“I mentioned that the connectivity was actually really quite surprising. It was able to go to the other side of my house and maintain a connection.”

This is Tech Today · 16:10 · May 2022 →

“It intelligently switches if a call comes in on your phone while you're listening to your laptop. Super convenient, no fiddling around.”

Tech Talk Central · 5:49 →

and 3 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“The first one was that when I was using this connected to two devices, um I think it was on the older version of Apple's Mac OS I was getting some weird Bluetooth issues with my mouse and my keyboard while also having this paired to my Mac…”

Steven Foster · 3:24 · Dec 2023 →

“You basically have to turn these headphones off and then back on again just to get them into Bluetooth pairing mode which is annoying.”

6 Months Later · 5:28 · Nov 2025 →

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“using these for story games on your PlayStation 5 or whatever you game on is definitely a viable option and the connection, there's less latency obviously with the new Bluetooth format of the Sonys versus the AirPods Max, but personally in…”

Seif Buys · 25:47 · Jun 2025 →

“Pairing the AirPods Max is as simple as putting them on and glancing at my phone. That's it. With Big Sur, iOS 14 and iPadOS 14, I don't have to think which device I'm using.”

ThisIsE · 4:38 · Jan 2021 →

“The beauty of being part of the Apple ecosystem is that things just work. Your devices pair with all your other devices and you can switch seamlessly between them.”

Marc Taraz Steiner · 8:39 · Jun 2025 →

“The reason why I would still recommend the AirPods Max to you is because of the ecosystem itself. It's just really easy especially if you're device switching”

ShaieJenny · 9:21 · Aug 2025 →

and 5 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“And forget about using the AirPods Max wired into a PC or Android because I just couldn't get it to work. Also I couldn't find a single lightning to lightning cable to connect it to my iPhone because well Apple's just dysfunctional port…”

This is Tech Today · 21:13 · May 2022 →

“the lightning port makes sense if you own an iPhone, I guess, but even here Apple is moving on to USB-C on the MacBook and the iPad”

MrMobile [Michael Fisher] · 8:35 · Dec 2020 →

“which may be the worst, flimsiest audio cable of all time at an embarrassingly short range.”

GregsGadgets · 2:41 · Jul 2023 →

“Apple supports USB-C lossless, but no 3.5 millimeter cable in the box.”

Headphones Pro Review · 4:34 · Apr 2026 →
The carrying caseA common complaint on both — 20% and 17% of reviewers liked them
What reviewers said about the carrying case (37 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“Sony does include a legitimate hard shell case to keep these expensive pair of headphones very protected. Compared to Apple on the other hand, where you're going to be getting this purse-looking sleeve that doesn't really protect them at…”

Erick · 1:50 · Jan 2024 →

“I recommend the Sony headphones for traveling just due to the fact of a case, you have the 3.5 millimeter which you have it present here on the XM6”

SimplyPops · 1:17 · May 2025 →

“I'm liking this canvas texture. Feels good. I could definitely see it fitting very easily inside my bag.”

Matt Pau · 2:00 →

“The Beats Studio Pro do that with what I think is the best headphone case on the market right now.”

Mark Ellis Reviews · 2:49 · Aug 2023 →

and 4 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“And the second thing that I noticed is that with the travel case being like this thin flat thing that uh Sony gives you with the headphones, instead of folding these up, um I guess into like a ball almost, you twist these cups down and…”

Steven Foster · 4:12 · Dec 2023 →

“They come with a protective case that covers the entirety of the headphones, so if you want to just toss them into a bag with a lot of other loose stuff, they'll be protected, but the case is also less convenient than the AirPods Max case”

6 Months Later · 0:35 · Nov 2022 →

“the XM5s had a really big chunky box. Not only was it big, it had a weird shape. Not only that, it also had this really weird zipper that went all around and that was very inconvenient.”

Victor Dia · 0:49 · Nov 2025 →

“For starters, the most glaring drawback of this new body is that it isn't fully collapsible, which means the 1000XM5s have a significantly larger case than all of its predecessors.”

GYMCADDY · 1:53 · May 2022 →

and 7 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“if you're just using them around the house, since the AirPods Max just slip right out of their case which gives it a smaller form factor and you don't have to constantly adjust and readjust them like you do in order to get the XM5s to fit…”

6 Months Later · 0:48 · Nov 2022 →

“The AirPods Max, I know a lot of people make fun of this thing and most reviewers out there don't think it's great or say they don't use it... If I didn't have this on, the AirPods Max could be getting scuffed and stuff like that”

Seif Buys · 16:16 · Jun 2025 →

“ye nahi badla hai, this is exactly the same, the smart case is also exactly the same”

Technical Guruji · 0:50 · Sep 2024 →

“it's super slim, easy to to carry with you and it's magnetic”

MGT - Max Games Tech · 1:59 · Apr 2021 →
What they criticised

“The lack of folding and the lack of a case, I might even count the smart case like that, but the lack of folding and, let's face it, there's no case basically, cause that smart case I really use, I haven't used that thing since uh since I…”

SimplyPops · 1:01 · May 2025 →

“The banging of the cups is another annoyance to me. Every time I take them out of the beautiful case, I can hear them banging, hitting each other, which leads me to believe that over time those sides of the cups will scuff and start to…”

ThisIsE · 9:17 · Jan 2021 →

“Now the smart case isn't bad in and of itself, as much as it is an amplifier for the AirPods' other annoyances. Namely, they're huge and they don't fold, so they're not very portable compared to most of the competition.”

MrMobile [Michael Fisher] · 7:55 · Dec 2020 →

“This case might be the worst case I've ever seen for any product I've ever boughten ever and certainly the worst headphone case I've ever seen.”

Colt Capperrune 2.0 · 1:21 · Nov 2022 →

and 10 more with something to say here

All 10 topics at a glance

Who this is counted from

All 75 covered both models — that is what makes the comparison worth anything: the same person, the same ears, the same expectations on both. 41 of them published a review of one of these two, shown below. Thumbnails open their video on YouTube.

Marques Brownlee, This is Tech Today, ShortCircuit, jakkuh, Digital Trends, Rozetked, Mike O'Brien, TechBar, CEONTHEMAKING, Andrew Ethan Zeng, Mark Ellis Reviews, crinacle and 63 more

How this is counted. One reviewer, one vote per topic — a reviewer who makes six points about sound counts once, so the numbers measure reception rather than talkativeness. Specifications and stated personal preferences are excluded; only assessments and direct comparisons count. A gap under 15 points is reported as level rather than as a winner.

No affiliate links, no sponsorship, and no payment from any brand mentioned. Updated September 2026.

SourceSignal.io

Find the signals hidden in search.

Source-attributed search intelligence. Evidence, not black-box SEO metrics.

© 2026 SourceSignalBuilt on live demand signals across search, YouTube and the web.