Skip to content

channel consensus

Apple AirPods Max vs Sony WH-1000XM5

What the channels assessed about each product.

Separate positive-reception counts. Larger or similar percentages do not establish a preference, a winner or equivalence.

Counted from 37 channels who reviewed both. We have not tested these headphones ourselves — counts describe channels; selected quotations link to located caption passages. 9 of them disclosed a sponsorship, free unit, paid promotion or ad on at least one of their two reviews; each is marked wherever they are quoted. Half of them covered the two within the same month of each other, and 28 of 37 within a year.

Apple AirPods Max review by Darko Audio
Apple AirPods Max review by TURN ONApple AirPods Max review by SoundGuysApple AirPods Max review by Karenna BoychukApple AirPods Max review by RecordingNOW

From 27 videos by the 37 channels who covered both

Apple AirPods Max

Reception data shown for

6 of 6 topics

Best on transparency mode — 10 of 11 channels liked it

Sony WH-1000XM5 review by Marques Brownlee
Sony WH-1000XM5 review by This is Tech TodaySony WH-1000XM5 review by ShortCircuitSony WH-1000XM5 review by Mike O'BrienSony WH-1000XM5 review by Mark Ellis Reviews

From 53 videos by the 37 channels who covered both

Sony WH-1000XM5

Reception data shown for

6 of 6 topics

Best on noise cancellation — 19 of 19 channels liked it

All 6 topics at a glance

Every topic at least 8 of the 37 channels discussed on both models. Percentages are the share who rated it positively. Pick one to jump to the evidence.

Topic AirPods Max Sony WH-1000XM5 Evidence type
Transparency mode91% 10 of 1127% 3 of 11Reception only
Design and build quality64% 7 of 1124% 5 of 21Reception only
Comfort and fit35% 6 of 1773% 19 of 26Reception only
Noise cancellation77% 10 of 13100% 19 of 19Reception only
Sound quality82% 9 of 1171% 17 of 24Reception only
Bluetooth and connectivity62% 5 of 867% 8 of 12Reception only

Topic observations

Each square is one channel; filled squares rated that topic positively. One channel counts once per topic, so these measure how many channels had a positive net assessment — not how loudly. A topic appears only where at least 8 channels covered it on both models.

Separate assessments by topic

Transparency mode

AirPods Max: 10 of 11 channels recorded positive reception. Sony WH-1000XM5: 3 of 11. These are separate product assessments, not direct preference votes.

Apple AirPods Max10 of 11 channels liked it

Sony WH-1000XM53 of 11 channels liked it

Marques Brownlee’s review, at 4:46
“Those are the best I've ever heard in any headphones. It sounds like you're not wearing headphones, you just hear everyone's voices and everything perfectly clearly”
Marques Brownlee · May 2022
Sony WH-1000XM5 Review: Two Steps Forward, One Step Back!
Watch this moment at 4:46 →
What channels said about Transparency mode (13 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“The XM5s transparency is still the one to beat and frankly it's awesome even compared to headphones from other brands. It could even rival the AirPods Max.”

Aaron X Loud and WirelessPaid promotion disclosed · 4:58 · Apr 2024 →

“with Sony's headphones you can adjust their ambient mode to your liking.”

GYMCADDYIncludes a paid ad · 12:18 · Aug 2023 →

“With its speak-to-chat feature, the XM5 allows you to talk with someone at the gym or a coffee shop without removing the headphones.”

The Source Audio Video Design Group · 2:46 · Dec 2023 →
What they criticised

“ambient mode on the sony is tier a so it's one tier lower still pretty reasonable it should be in tier b and not tier a”

DHRME · 8:51 · Dec 2023 →

“Oh, that is not a very good ambient mode.”

ShortCircuitIncludes a paid ad · 7:54 · May 2022 →

“Sony's ambient mode is good, but it still has that slight digital hiss and robotic tint to voices that reminds you you're listening through microphones.”

Everything Under Control · 4:42 · Dec 2025 →

“my voice is actually really quiet. I feel like I need to raise the volume of my voice to be able to hear it more clearly”

Elly Awesome Tech · 2:01 · Jun 2024 →

and 1 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“Those are the best I've ever heard in any headphones. It sounds like you're not wearing headphones, you just hear everyone's voices and everything perfectly clearly”

Marques Brownlee · 4:46 · May 2022 →

“Apple's transparency mode is the best I've ever heard.”

MrMobile [Michael Fisher] · 2:20 · Dec 2020 →

“These have the best transparency mode that I have ever heard in an audio product, bar none.”

ShortCircuitIncludes a paid ad · 14:42 · Apr 2026 →

“Transparent mode is incredible on these headphones.”

Colt Capperrune 2.0Paid promotion disclosed · 6:41 · Nov 2022 →

and 1 more with something to say here

What they criticised

No channel said this in words we could verify.

Design and build quality

AirPods Max: 7 of 11 channels recorded positive reception. Sony WH-1000XM5: 5 of 21. These are separate product assessments, not direct preference votes.

Apple AirPods Max7 of 11 channels liked it

Sony WH-1000XM55 of 21 channels liked it

This is Tech Today’s review, at 27:33
“The one thing that sinks is that the AirPods Max have an exceptionally high quality build and the transparency mode is unreal.”
This is Tech Today · May 2022
THE DEFINITIVE Sony WH-1000XM5 Review & Comparison by an AUDIO ENGINEER
Watch this moment at 27:33 →
What channels said about Design and build quality (30 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“Now the 1000XM5 from Sony on the other hand makes a solid first impression with a fresh and clean design, clear sound, and an even better ANC.”

Audio Zone · 1:46 · Jul 2023 →

“The minimalist design is sleek and professional, making them a great choice for the office or travel.”

Pro Product Comparison · 1:32 →

“I think durability deserves a special mention with the XM5s and they are a bit of a winner in that area, which is a surprise because when you first get these and first get them out the box, they are unnervingly light.”

Mark Ellis ReviewsFree unit from Sony · 4:03 · Aug 2022 →

“Sony wins in portability, Apple wins aesthetically.”

SimplyPopsPaid promotion disclosed · 2:42 · May 2025 →

and 1 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“If you look at the hinge design here, this has been a notorious issue online and I have seen examples of this hinge breaking. To get down to this lightweight, Sony did use quite a lot of plastic, but the hinge here is really the weak point.”

RecordingNOW · 3:50 · Mar 2025 →

“These feel really plasticky and really cheap and the design of it is absolutely beautiful. But once you actually hold them in your hands, they feel extremely cheap, they're extremely flexible.”

Nikias Molina · 1:01 · Jun 2022 →

“Also, the ear cushion material and headband material like a lot of other headphones in this price range is made out of a fake leather material and it's not as breathable as I'd like.”

6 Months Later · 3:27 · Nov 2022 →

“The only downside I see here is that you're not going to be getting that premium sort of feel, especially for the price you're paying for these.”

Erick · 1:12 · Jan 2024 →

and 13 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“The one thing that sinks is that the AirPods Max have an exceptionally high quality build and the transparency mode is unreal.”

This is Tech Today · 27:33 · May 2022 →

“you still cannot deny its iconic design and stellar aluminum and mesh build quality.”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 6:02 · Apr 2023 →

“I'd give these a solid seven out of 10 in terms of like the design.”

UrAvgConsumer · 4:03 · Dec 2020 →

“I think they're built really well actually. They're all metal. They feel very sturdy, they feel very premium.”

Colt Capperrune 2.0Paid promotion disclosed · 0:57 · Nov 2022 →

and 1 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“And the AirPods Max are notoriously annoying to travel with even though I still try to make it work.”

Marques Brownlee · 3:06 · May 2022 →

“it feels as though the mesh is starting to get kind of loose after the past few years of use.”

AppleInsider · 0:49 · Jun 2024 →

“the Spigen skin cover is that is also prone to scratches just like the XM5 uh which is right there I do have one.”

Booredatwork.com · 5:33 · Jun 2024 →

Comfort and fit

AirPods Max: 6 of 17 channels recorded positive reception. Sony WH-1000XM5: 19 of 26. These are separate product assessments, not direct preference votes.

Apple AirPods Max6 of 17 channels liked it

Sony WH-1000XM519 of 26 channels liked it

ThisIsE’s review, at 2:04
“Although very heavy, some 150 grams on top of other brands, the weight is very interestingly distributed and the usual tension is not clamping my ears, but rather the tops of my head, resulting in a somewhat…”
ThisIsE · 485k subscribers · Jan 2021
Apple AirPods Max Review & Impressions after 2 weeks (Space Grey)
Watch this moment at 2:04 →
What channels said about Comfort and fit (46 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“And when I say light, they are very light. With the AirPods Max, it's got such a big headphone band that it's really uncomfortable when traveling, plus the AirPods Max are very, very heavy, so for traveling, it just did not convince me.”

Nikias Molina · 1:25 · Jun 2022 →

“the XM5 just kind of feel like they're resting on top of my head, which makes them an excellent choice for traveling or just anyone that wears their headphones for longer periods of time.”

CEONTHEMAKING · 2:07 · May 2024 →

“I still like the XM5, that's still one of my favorites because A, comfortable, didn't have a tough clamp, microphones are like god tier, so I'm happy to save money and go for the XM5”

DHRME · 14:26 · May 2026 →

“The combination of ABS sliders, swivelling earcups, and plush memory foam within the headband positions it amongst the most comfortable over-ear headphones in its class.”

Audio Zone · 1:51 →

and 15 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“I find that it isn't quite as comfortable as larger headbands maybe that's just because the pressure is more localized and in one spot and that's one of the main reasons why Apple designed their AirPods Max is with this large mesh area it…”

Karl Conrad · 3:31 · May 2022 →

“the interior of the ear cups is very shallow. So my ears are clearly pressing against the fabric inside of these ear cups and it can feel kind of claustrophobic.”

RecordingNOW · 2:17 · Mar 2025 →

“The shape of the headband because it's rounded, it's very uncomfortable, so after two hours of wearing, you'll start to feel pain on your head.”

REC Anything · 13:51 →

“because the problem was the head the uh the head cups inside always hit my head hit my ears so I couldn't wear the thing for a very long time”

Almando Gooden · 0:43 · May 2025 →

and 2 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“Even though they're heavier than the XM5s, I actually find the AirPods Max to be a more comfortable set of headphones for a few reasons. First one is the mesh material used here on the mesh canopy. It allows the heat generated from your…”

6 Months Later · 3:31 · Nov 2022 →

“Although very heavy, some 150 grams on top of other brands, the weight is very interestingly distributed and the usual tension is not clamping my ears, but rather the tops of my head, resulting in a somewhat evenly distributed experience.”

ThisIsE · 2:04 · Jan 2021 →

“I have been using the AirPods Pros for editing video and I wanted something a little bit nicer a little bit more comfortable to wear.”

Air Photography · 0:39 · Dec 2020 →

“I tried on the Apple pair first and I really liked them, super comfortable, the music was amazing, like the the quality of the music”

Karenna Boychuk · 4:55 · Jan 2025 →

and 3 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“Because of that material choice, the AirPods Max are just not comfortable and you cannot listen to them for long extended periods of time without your head starting to hurt.”

Marc Taraz Steiner · 1:11 · Jun 2025 →

“I've seen a lot of people complain about the weight of these saying that they're pretty heavy. This is substantially heavier than a lot of headphones out there right now”

UrAvgConsumer · 3:02 · Dec 2020 →

“if I had to be critical I'd say they're on the heavier side so you might run into some discomfort during longer listening sessions.”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 6:14 · Apr 2023 →

“wearing these for a long period of time might get a little uncomfortable.”

Erick · 1:30 · Jan 2024 →

and 10 more with something to say here

Noise cancellation

AirPods Max: 10 of 13 channels recorded positive reception. Sony WH-1000XM5: 19 of 19. These are separate product assessments, not direct preference votes.

Apple AirPods Max10 of 13 channels liked it

Sony WH-1000XM519 of 19 channels liked it

Erick’s review, at 2:50
“For the active noise cancellation and transparency mode that you'll find on both of these headphones, I think the AirPods Max takes it, especially in the transparency mode. I just think the microphones that…”
Erick · 12k subscribers · Jan 2024
Sony WH-1000XM5 vs AirPods Max | Which should you buy in 2024?
Watch this moment at 2:50 →
What channels said about Noise cancellation (33 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“Overall though, the Sony XM5s have been my go to I think just with that combination of sound canceling that doesn't annoy me, a sound profile that to me at least sounds good and I enjoy both for voice and also for music.”

Steven Foster · 5:42 · Dec 2023 →

“This was the best active noise cancelling experience I've had with a pair of headphones. It was noticeably better and more quieter on the Mark 5s compared to the AirPods Pros or even the Mark 3s”

Karl Conrad · 5:28 · May 2022 →

“If you're after a premium listening experience with incredible sound quality, world-class noise cancellation, and all-day comfort, the Sony WH-1000XM5 is hands down the winner.”

Pro Product Comparison · 3:30 →

“The XM5 automatically optimize the noise cancelling based on environmental measurements. On the XM4 you could do that, but you had to use an app.”

Digital Trends · 6:07 · May 2022 →

and 17 more with something to say here

What they criticised

No channel said this in words we could verify.

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“For the active noise cancellation and transparency mode that you'll find on both of these headphones, I think the AirPods Max takes it, especially in the transparency mode. I just think the microphones that are in the AirPods Max make…”

Erick · 2:50 · Jan 2024 →

“the active noise cancellation is also beyond top notch. It does the best job in blocking out external noise to the point where I almost forgot the hum of the plane on flights until I stopped using them.”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 5:16 · Apr 2023 →

“It'll totally cancel out the heat noise, but I can still hear people talking. So it like cuts out all this weird background noises, but still allows actual people voices and talking to come through.”

Chrissyx Jonez · 14:27 · Jan 2023 →

“So I give the win to the AirPods Max for active noise cancellation.”

Booredatwork.com · 12:55 · May 2025 →

and 6 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“I find the ANC on the AirPods Max very aggressive.”

KwasiTechSpace · 1:57 · Jun 2024 →

“I actually didn't find the AirPods Max noise canceling to be as good as some people online say I think it's because of the physical seal is not as good due to having this rectangular earcup shape and also not having these really…”

RecordingNOWPaid promotion disclosed · 5:01 · May 2025 →

Sound quality

AirPods Max: 9 of 11 channels recorded positive reception. Sony WH-1000XM5: 17 of 24. These are separate product assessments, not direct preference votes.

Apple AirPods Max9 of 11 channels liked it

Sony WH-1000XM517 of 24 channels liked it

Andrew Ethan Zeng’s review, at 4:48
“plugging these headphones in via the 3.5mm adapter made the experience even richer and it's truly as good as it gets. Honestly it sounds as close to true lossless audio as possible to the point where I really…”
Andrew Ethan Zeng · 433k subscribers · Apr 2023
Apple AirPods Max – 2 Years Later: Still Worth It?
Watch this moment at 4:48 →
What channels said about Sound quality (31 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“Sony has their own proprietary sound enhancements as well, and if you're using a Sony source say like the A306 or the ZX707 DAPs, then I'd be hard pressed to find a better portable combo in this price range.”

Moon Audio · 3:22 · Aug 2023 →

“The audio quality of the Sony WH-1000XM5 is what truly captivated us. Described as detailed, musical and transparent, these award-winning headphones excel at handling any genre you throw their way.”

Audio Zone · 4:48 →

“my first impressions of the XM5s sound quality is really good; the bass was exceptional, but it could sometimes overpower the vocals and make everything sound muffled.”

loveaction alyssa · 5:44 · Feb 2023 →

“I like Sony's treble and midrange within their earbuds and uh over ear headphones because it's kind of a soft treble.”

New Stuff TV · 5:28 · Aug 2022 →

and 11 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“if you want a headphones for loudness, the Sony 1000XM5 is not the one. You can go for the Skullcandy Crusher headphones that have built in fourth base.”

AudioTribe · 8:32 →

“the XM5s, the XM4s as well as the XM3s are always some of the worst sounding ANC headphones that I have ever used.”

crinacle · 3:03 · Jun 2025 →

“By default, I think the XM5s are a little heavy in the mids and definitely a bit heavy with the bass.”

6 Months Later · 2:05 · Nov 2022 →

“The one caveat with the noise canceling, similar to the B&W PX7 S2e headphones, is that the base quantity is increased when the noise cancellation is active”

The Source Audio Video Design Group · 2:25 · Dec 2023 →

and 1 more with something to say here

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“plugging these headphones in via the 3.5mm adapter made the experience even richer and it's truly as good as it gets. Honestly it sounds as close to true lossless audio as possible to the point where I really highly doubt you'd be able to…”

Andrew Ethan Zeng · 4:48 · Apr 2023 →

“The next thing I love about the AirPods Max is their sound quality. Now yes, while they don't support high-quality music streaming codecs through Bluetooth like the XM5s do, to me they still achieve better sound quality.”

6 Months Later · 4:11 · Nov 2022 →

“I don't regret purchasing the AirPods Max per se because first off, they produce fantastic sound, but most of all, they fit the Apple ecosystem perfectly and respectively my lifestyle and workflow.”

ThisIsE · 0:37 · Jan 2021 →

“if you listen to a lot of drum and bass, techno, hip-hop, modern pop, you might lean towards the Apple AirPods Max.”

Darko Audio · 17:48 · Oct 2022 →

and 5 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“If you're into bass heavy club style music, you might feel a bit underwhelming. There's definitely a warmth to the vocals.”

Kevin The Tech NinjaPaid promotion disclosed · 8:26 · May 2025 →

“The note definition in the sub-bass, so we're talking 100 Hz and below, it definitely leaves something to be desired.”

Colt Capperrune 2.0Paid promotion disclosed · 7:26 · Nov 2022 →

Bluetooth and connectivity

AirPods Max: 5 of 8 channels recorded positive reception. Sony WH-1000XM5: 8 of 12. These are separate product assessments, not direct preference votes.

Apple AirPods Max5 of 8 channels liked it

Sony WH-1000XM58 of 12 channels liked it

Marc Taraz Steiner’s review, at 8:36
“The beauty of being part of the Apple ecosystem is that things just work. Your devices pair with all your other devices and you can switch seamlessly between them.”
Marc Taraz Steiner · Jun 2025
Sony WH-1000XM6 vs Airpods Max | It's Not Even Close
Watch this moment at 8:36 →
What channels said about Bluetooth and connectivity (12 quoted)

Sony WH-1000XM5

What they praised

“whereas the Sony's on the other hand, you can plug these in just with a 3.5 millimeter headphone jack and you can still use them as regular old headphones. You don't have to turn it on.”

Tausif Hussain · 8:57 · Dec 2023 →

“You can also connect to two Bluetooth devices simultaneously, making it easy to switch between a laptop for work and a phone for calls.”

finderBinder · 3:08 →

“I mentioned that the connectivity was actually really quite surprising. It was able to go to the other side of my house and maintain a connection.”

This is Tech TodayFree unit from Sony · 16:08 · May 2022 →

“It intelligently switches if a call comes in on your phone while you're listening to your laptop. Super convenient, no fiddling around.”

Tech Talk CentralPaid promotion disclosed · 5:46 →

and 1 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“unfortunately the Sony cannot do audio over USB C”

DHRME · 15:58 · Dec 2023 →

Apple AirPods Max

What they praised

“Pairing the AirPods Max is as simple as putting them on and glancing at my phone. That's it. With Big Sur, iOS 14 and iPadOS 14, I don't have to think which device I'm using.”

ThisIsE · 4:35 · Jan 2021 →

“The beauty of being part of the Apple ecosystem is that things just work. Your devices pair with all your other devices and you can switch seamlessly between them.”

Marc Taraz Steiner · 8:36 · Jun 2025 →

“the Airpod Maxes are kind of the easiest to integrate into all of your technology because they'll just seamlessly work with everything else”

Karenna Boychuk · 2:23 · Jan 2025 →

“the AirPods Max automatically connects to my phone automatically connects to my MacBook”

Seif Buys Paid promotion disclosed · 1:06 · Jun 2025 →

and 1 more with something to say here

What they criticised

“because of course there's no 3.5 millimeter headphone jack either.”

MrMobile [Michael Fisher] · 9:02 · Dec 2020 →

All 6 topics at a glance

Limits of this comparison

Coverage of both products does not mean a channel directly compared every property. Conditions, firmware, fit and test dates can differ. Missing evidence does not establish a tie. These counts summarize separate assessments; a preference requires a supported comparative passage.

All 6 topics at a glance

Who this is counted from

All 37 channels covered both models. This limits the coverage panel, but does not establish identical tests or direct preferences. 26 of them published a review of one of these two, shown below. Thumbnails open YouTube.

Marques Brownlee, This is Tech Today, ShortCircuit, Mike O'Brien, Mark Ellis Reviews, Darko Audio, Aaron X Loud and Wireless, SimplyPops, Droider, 6 Months Later, SoundGuys, DHRME and 25 more

How this is counted. One channel, one net assessment per product and topic. Positive and negative claim signs are combined; a net-zero channel counts in the denominator. Specifications and unsupported publication filings are excluded. Positive reception is not a preference.

Caption location supports the quotation link; it does not by itself verify meaning or attribution. Model checks are not comprehensive human review. Selected public findings require contextual judgement.

These public editorial pages take no affiliate commission or sponsorship. Commissioned analysis is a separate paid service. Page generated October 2026 from saved observations; this is not a new collection date.

Is one of these yours?

Commission a report on your product and the competitors relevant to your question, with reviewer recommendations, comparisons and trade-offs supported by quotations and timestamped links.

Share your product, relevant rivals and a question. We assess review coverage, then reply with what it can support and a scope to discuss.