Skip to content
SourceSignal.io

Marshall Monitor III problems

Of the 30 channels counted here, 6 of 16 objected to noise cancellation — the most common complaint about the Marshall Monitor III. Next: design and build quality (3 of 17); the carrying case (3 of 10).

30 channels 37 videos Page generated How this is counted

3 of 30 were sponsored by Marshall or got a free unit; 1 disclosed another paid promotion or ad; public editorial analysis; commissioned reports are a separate paid service.

Marshall Monitor III: where the complaints land

Ranked by how many channels objected, not by score — a topic most people liked can still be the one that trips buyers up. Pick a topic for the complaints behind it.

liked it had a problem split Each square is one channel

  1. Noise cancellation6 of 16 had a problem8 liked it · 2 split
  2. Design and build quality3 of 17 had a problem13 liked it · 1 split
  3. The carrying case3 of 10 had a problem7 liked it
  4. Sound quality2 of 17 had a problem15 liked it
  5. Comfort and fit1 of 23 had a problem21 liked it · 1 split
The exact counts, including channels with no tie to the brand
TopicLiked itNo disclosed relationship with MarshallComplaints
Noise cancellation50% 8 of 1646% 6 of 136 objected · 2 split
Design and build quality76% 13 of 1777% 10 of 133 objected · 1 split
The carrying case70% 7 of 1067% 6 of 93 objected
Sound quality88% 15 of 1792% 12 of 132 objected
Comfort and fit91% 21 of 2389% 17 of 191 objected · 1 split

This page covers complaints only. See what all 30 channels concluded, including what they praised.

Marshall Monitor III: what they actually said

Every topic channels objected to, the complaints first. One voice per channel, only from channels counted on that side; those with no disclosed tie to the brand come first.

Noise cancellation

6 of 16 had a problem · 8 liked it · 2 split

Had a problem 6

“Low frequency sounds like engine noise are effectively blocked, but higher frequency sounds can still sneak through.”
Audio ZoneOct 2024at 3:29 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

Liked it 8

“I would happily give these guys a 7.5. I I'm going to say eight, but I'm not I'm not I don't think they're at that eight at the eight level. But 7.5 works for me. Again, it's not knocking out some audio is making it a lot quieter.”
RonOnTechJun 2026at 29:55 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)
More from both sides (2 more quotes)
“against the rumbling noises of traffic and public transport, it's simply not as silent.”
Aaron X Loud and WirelessPaid promotion disclosedMar 2025at 6:11 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)
“when it comes to wind, these were very, very usable. There is no separate mode for wind noise reduction, but in both ANC and transparency, it could deal with moderate wind speeds.”
DHRMEJan 2025at 7:14 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

Design and build quality

3 of 17 had a problem · 13 liked it · 1 split

Had a problem 3

“They're solidly built but have a slight downside with the folding mechanism, which can twist awkwardly when worn and creak under pressure.”
Audio ZoneOct 2024at 0:53 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

Liked it 13

“Something that continues to be one of its biggest selling features setting itself apart from almost every other high-end consumer wireless headphone is how rock solid these are.”
Tom’s GuideOct 2024at 2:32 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)
More from both sides (1 more quote)
“the Monitor IIIs are very durable. I'm not worried about throwing these in my bag, they're not going to get banged up.”
Paul AntillDec 2024at 2:46 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

The carrying case

3 of 10 had a problem · 7 liked it

Had a problem 3

“I didn't expect the case to be so bulky”
Jheng Gabriel (GAB)Mar 2026at 2:07 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

Liked it 7

“the quality on this is amazing”
Unboxing with EddieJun 2025at 2:28 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)
More from both sides (1 more quote)
“this red velvet interior? Aside from just giving the headphones a soft protective place to live, this has to be one of the most aesthetically pleasing headphone cases I've ever seen. The red contrasting with the black and then the brass…”
CEONTHEMAKINGSponsored by MarshallDec 2024at 0:45 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

Sound quality

2 of 17 had a problem · 15 liked it

Had a problem 2

“Which has the best sound staging? For that, I vote for the Sennheisers because its background detail is better separated and more distinct than the rest of the headphones in this group, not just the Marshalls.”
Aaron X Loud and WirelessPaid promotion disclosedMar 2025at 10:07 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

Liked it 15

“Look, it's Marshall. These are tuned for rock and metal right out of the box and they're tuned very beautifully and very tastefully if you ask me.”
RecordingNOWAug 2025at 5:47 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)
More from both sides (1 more quote)
“it's basically it's a balanced sound, a tad bit of bass, but you can basically listen to anything you want to”
RJ UploadsJul 2025at 19:27 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

Comfort and fit

1 of 23 had a problem · 21 liked it · 1 split

Had a problem 1

No quotable complaint among the 1 who objected. A quote has to be found in the video’s captions, state a clear verdict and come from a review rather than a setup guide. Hear them at the moment they raised it:

Liked it 21

“The padded headband does not dig into your scalp after hours of wear and the memory foam ear cups form a soft seal around your ears without putting them in a chokehold.”
Unboxed by CromaMay 2025at 1:15 (watch on YouTube, opens in a new tab)

Back to the ranking

What nobody complained about

Not one of the channels we counted raised a problem with these, which is worth as much as the list above.

  • Battery life 11 of 11 liked it

Quick answers

What are the biggest downsides of the Marshall Monitor III?
The flaws and issues most often raised, ranked by how many of the 30 channels objected: noise cancellation (6 of 16 objected), design and build quality (3 of 17 objected), the carrying case (3 of 10 objected).
What did nobody complain about?
Not one of the 30 channels raised a problem with battery life.
What is the reception among channels with no disclosed relationship?
On comfort and fit, 21 of 23 channels rated it positively (91%). Counting only the 19 who disclosed no sponsorship, free unit or ad from Marshall, it is 17 of 19 (89%).

Marshall Monitor III channels and sources

Every channel counted on this page, most-watched first — the one you have already seen is probably near the top. Thumbnails open the video on YouTube.

Marshall Monitor III VS Bose Quietcomfort Ultra VS Sony WH-1000XM5 | SURPRISING RESULTS!CEONTHEMAKING181k viewsMarshall Monitor III ANC: Underrated!Joshua Chang73k viewsMarshall Monitor III ANC Review vs Bose, AirPods, Sony, Sennheiser 🤔Aaron X Loud and Wireless58k viewsMarshall Monitor III ANC Review | Buy or Skip?!Tom’s Guide55k viewsMarshall Monitor III ANC Review: Worth Upgrading from Monitor II?Paul Antill43k viewsWhy these headphones are different! Marshall Monitor III ANC reviewM1M Tech Channel42k viewsMarshall Monitor III ANC: kosmiczna bateria! | RECENZJAnieantyfan35k views搖滾DNA注入！Marshall Monitor III A.N.C 實測｜100小時播放時間｜音質、ANC、通話測試｜#廣東話 #特約專題 #產品介紹Price.com.hk 香港格價網35k viewsОгляд нових повнорозмірних навушників Marshall Monitor III і порівняння із Marshall…Soundmag — салон персонального аудіо29k viewsThese cans ROCK! Marshall Monitor III ANC ReviewDHRME29k viewsMarshall Monitor III – Better in Every Way than the Major VTechnodeus27k views【科技說】原來功能、體驗、外觀都能兼顧，給我不選Marshall的理由｜Marshall Monitor III A.N.C.主動式抗噪藍牙耳罩式耳機｜開箱EP54TechTeller26k views
Show all 30 channels
Comparo Los Marshall Monitor III Contra los Bosé QuietComfort Ultra y Los Sony WH-1000XM5CEONTHEMAKING Español25k viewsНОВЫЕ Marshall Monitor III (2024) vs Monitor II 👀 — Стоит Обновляться? [НОВОСТЬ]MyChooz 🎧24k viewsMarshall Monitor III ANC Review: These Headphones ROCK!RecordingNOW21k viewsBezdrátová sluchátka Marshall Monitor III ANC: spojení retro stylu a moderních funkcíLukas Fronk12k viewsEndlos dein Sound - First Look Marshall Monitor III ANCHIFI DE6k viewsMarshall Monitor III — Рок-н-ролл или переплата? Мой личный отзыв.Нето4k viewsMarshall Monitor II ANC VS Marshall Monitor III ANC — які навушники обрати?Citrus4k viewsMarshall Monitor III vs Sony WH-1000XM6 Technical ComparisonTechnical Earbuds4k viewsMarshall Monitor III ANC - Unboxing #marshall #noisecancellation #audiophileUnboxing with Eddie3k viewsMarshall Monitor III review | Style with silence, and great sound!Unboxed by Croma3k viewsMarshall Monitor III...my thoughtsRJ Uploads2k viewsMarshall MONITOR III A.N.C. Headphones | Unboxing & ReviewRonOnTech2k viewsThese Headphones Look INSANE 😍 Marshall Monitor III ANC UnboxingJheng Gabriel (GAB)1k viewsMarshall Monitor III ANC: Best Headphones Under ₹30000 in 2026?Tech House667 viewsMARSHALL MONITOR III A.N.C. — Rozpakowanie i zawartość pudełkaHardReset_pl107 viewsMARSHALL MONITOR III – Microphone Test vs iPhone 12HardReset.Info107 viewsMarshall Monitor 3 ANC vs Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphone - Which One to Buy?Audio Zone20k viewsMarshall Monitor 3 VS Bose QuietComfort Ultra - ANC King?Tech Syndicate6k views

How this is counted

One channel, one vote per topic. A channel who makes six points about sound counts once, so the numbers measure reception rather than talkativeness. Specifications and stated personal preferences are excluded; only assessments and direct comparisons count. A topic appears only where at least eight channels discussed it.

Split means a channel’s praise and criticism of a topic cancelled out. They count in the total and on neither side.

We have not tested this product. Counts describe channels with eligible assessments. Selected quotations link to their located caption passage. 3 of the 30 were sponsored by Marshall or got a free unit from them, and 1 more disclosed a paid promotion or an ad. Each is marked wherever they are quoted, and the summary shows every verdict with and without them.

No disclosed relationship is the subset without a recorded sponsorship, gifted-unit classification or generic paid-promotion marker. Unrelated ads can be labelled separately; affiliate disclosures are not comprehensively audited by this table. Missing arrangements remain unknown. This subset does not prove independence or a sponsorship effect.

Selected quotations are located in saved captions. Location is distinct from semantic support, product attribution and model checks; it is not comprehensive human review.

These public editorial pages take no affiliate commission or sponsorship. Commissioned reports are a separate paid service. Page generated from saved observations, not newly collected reviews.

A commissioned report scopes the products, questions and available evidence with your team. It can distinguish recurring observations, meaningful exceptions and open questions.

Is this your product, or a rival’s?

Commission a report on your product and the competitors relevant to your question, with reviewer recommendations, comparisons and trade-offs supported by quotations and timestamped links.

Share your product, relevant rivals and a question. We assess review coverage, then reply with what it can support and a scope to discuss.

How the analysis works

Or email contact@sourcesignal.io