What reviewers complain about

Edifier Stax Spirit S5 problems

Edifier Stax Spirit S5 review by GadgetryTech
Edifier Stax Spirit S5 review by JuanBagnellEdifier Stax Spirit S5 review by Geeky StuffEdifier Stax Spirit S5 review by High Tech PointEdifier Stax Spirit S5 review by Brian Unboxed

From 43 videos by 37 reviewers

The most common complaints about the Edifier Stax Spirit S5 concern noise cancelling, comfort and connection.

Everything below is a complaint a named reviewer made on camera, with the moment it was said. Topics nobody objected to are listed at the end.

We have not tested this product. Every number is a count of independent reviewers, and links to the second they said it. No affiliate links and no payment from any brand mentioned.

This page covers complaints only. See what all 37 reviewers concluded, including what they praised.

Where the complaints land

Ranked by how many reviewers objected, not by score — a topic most people liked can still be the one that trips buyers up.

TopicLiked itComplaints
Noise cancellation8% 2 of 2521 objected
Comfort and fit65% 15 of 233 objected
Bluetooth and connectivity62% 5 of 83 objected
Design and build quality75% 12 of 162 objected

What they actually said

Every complaint we could verify against the transcript, newest and longest first, one voice per reviewer.

Noise cancellation

21 of 25 reviewers who discussed it had a problem with it

“Although these headphones sound amazing, there are some features missing which uh could uh be a deal breaker for some. The lack of ANC. So, as most of the headphones in this space do have active noise cancellation, and these are missing…”

High Tech Point · Jul 2024 · 1:54 →

“Now one thing that you can't change in the application and something that I've kind of avoided saying in this video is of course the active noise cancellation. And that's because for $499, it doesn't have noise cancellation.”

Copper vs Glass · Jul 2024 · 7:50 →

“you're not going to get active noise cancelling with these and so that's one thing I just wanted to highlight... these are really focused on audio, not so much noise cancelling.”

EBPMAN Tech Reviews · Jul 2024 · 4:06 →

“One thing I do feel that's missing though is active noise cancellation. I would have liked to have seen that on the spec list, especially for the £500 asking price.”

KitGuruTech · Jul 2024 · 5:58 →

“these headphones do not have active noise cancellation technology or ANC for short, which is actually quite surprising and disappointing”

TotallydubbedHD · Jul 2024 · 9:41 →

“There is no active noise cancellation and that makes the recommendation a little more specific than an all-rounder travel can.”

JuanBagnell · Aug 2024 · 9:02 →

and 10 more with something to say here

Comfort and fit

3 of 23 reviewers who discussed it had a problem with it

“The problem is with the design. So this headband is uniform in terms of strength and thickness throughout the entire length, which means that when you flex it, the only part that moves is the middle part. This leads to inadequate clamping…”

MOBHouse · Oct 2024 · 1:37 →

“And they do get slightly warm, mainly with the leather earpads, but this does mean you get pretty decent passive noise isolation with them.”

Picky Audio · Sep 2024 · 1:55 →

“I do give them a a demerit on the headband... that I don't know, that should be a little softer”

RonOnTech · Jul 2024 · 1:37 →

“the headband was nicer on the S3 compared to the S5... the headband padding is very meager”

DHRME · Jul 2024 · 0:59 →

“this adds about an additional 32 grams to the headphones when you put on the cool mesh.”

Dem Crumblies Tech · Jul 2024 · 3:14 →

and 1 more with something to say here

Design and build quality

2 of 16 reviewers who discussed it had a problem with it

“Con number two, although they're boasting about their new design on the headset adjustment, I'm really not a fan. Look how loose it is. The simplest little shake drops these like a bad habit.”

Brannon No d · Jul 2024 · 18:19 →

“that is where I would probably not recommend these if you're going to listen to them in public because they do leak quite a bit of sound”

Gamesky · Jul 2024 · 9:16 →

and 2 more with something to say here

Back to the summary

What nobody complained about

Not one of the reviewers we counted raised a problem with these, which is worth as much as the list above.

  • Microphone quality on calls — 8 of 8 liked it
  • Sound quality — 33 of 34 liked it

Who this is counted from

Thumbnails open each reviewer's video on YouTube.

How this is counted. One reviewer, one vote per topic — a reviewer who makes six points about sound counts once, so the numbers measure reception rather than talkativeness. Specifications and stated personal preferences are excluded; only assessments and direct comparisons count. A topic appears only where at least eight reviewers discussed it.

No affiliate links, no sponsorship, and no payment from any brand mentioned. Updated September 2026.

SourceSignal.io

Find the signals hidden in search.

Source-attributed search intelligence. Evidence, not black-box SEO metrics.

© 2026 SourceSignalBuilt on live demand signals across search, YouTube and the web.